Long-term care insurance would burden adult children of aging boomers

Article content material

By Bonnie-Jeanne MacDonald, Samir Sinha, Alyssa Brierley

Article content material

A recent editorial within the Globe and Mail proposed the creation of a nationwide long-term care (LTC) insurance coverage program just like the Canada or Quebec Pension Plans (CPP/QPP). Though it is a well-intentioned and doubtlessly beneficial coverage possibility, it’s vital to clear up some frequent misconceptions. Such an answer is not going to resolve the instant clear and current hazard for LTC in Canada: the upcoming and mounting fiscal pressures dealing with Canada’s rapidly aging population with its struggling LTC techniques.

Article content material

Article content material

Understanding the context

Throughout the peak of the pandemic in 2021, when the systemic challenges in our LTC techniques have been laid naked, the oldest child boomer had simply turned 76, an age at which nearly all of Canadians don’t require care. This disconnect in public perceptions will turn out to be more and more evident over the approaching decade, as child boomers age into their 80s and start requiring general ranges of care which have by no means been seen in our historical past.

Article content material

Article content material

Utilizing a posh inhabitants microsimulation mannequin to venture Canada’s future LTC prices — together with nursing properties and residential care — we on the Nationwide Institute of Ageing (NIA) at Toronto Metropolitan College discovered that if Canada continues on its present monitor, the price of publicly funded LTC will greater than triple in 30 years (in as we speak’s {dollars}). A mixture of different components, such because the rising worldwide labour scarcity for health-care employees, will drive these figures up additional.

Like LTC, the CPP/QPP may also have dramatically escalating prices over the subsequent three many years as our inhabitants ages. Nevertheless, the CPP/QPP is provided with a checking account of greater than $500 billion, together with a well-planned persevering with influx of contributions.

Article content material

The important thing to the CPP/QPP’s success is that these packages have been arrange six many years in the past, that means the newborn boomers who helped pay into the CPP/QPP whereas working may also be paid out from it whereas retired (in any other case often called a “partially pre-funded” pension program).

LTC, nonetheless, is financed out of normal tax income — there is no such thing as a devoted fund to cowl the prices. Even when a nationwide LTC insurance coverage program have been arrange as we speak, it will take many years for this system to be “totally mature” and pay out totally funded advantages to new retirees, too late for the newborn boomers who will want them.

Attempting to have our cake and eat it too

Alternatively, if we create a nationwide LTC insurance coverage program that asks the youthful era to right away fund new LTC advantages to older individuals (i.e., those that haven’t paid into it), there can be a serious subject of intergenerational equity, significantly provided that this youthful era may also be referred to as on to supply important ranges of voluntary care to older Canadians.

Article content material

To this point, grownup youngsters have been the spine of the particular provision of LTC in Canada. Analysis by the NIA has discovered that 75 per cent of all care within the dwelling, amongst these receiving government-funded dwelling care, is being supplied informally by shut relations and mates.

Nevertheless, together with being the biggest era in historical past and having the longest life expectations, child boomers are additionally the primary era to have comparatively few youngsters. Primarily based on the demographics, the NIA estimates unpaid relations would want to extend their efforts by 40 per cent simply to maintain up with the rising care wants of their growing older mother and father. And never solely will every particular person have to do extra, however many extra individuals might want to scale back their working hours or depart their jobs altogether to supply that care, because the variety of seniors needing help greater than doubles.

Article content material

Wanting forward

We already know that as child boomers transfer additional into retirement, increasingly more working-age grownup youngsters could have the burden of getting to decide on between caring for his or her older family members, or looking for the present and future monetary curiosity of themselves and their youngsters.

Creating a conventional nationwide LTC insurance coverage program that makes an attempt to finance the care wants of child boomers will solely make the pressures on this working-generation even heavier by imposing on them a brand new double payroll tax: they might pay right into a program to help an unprepared growing older inhabitants, whereas additionally being compelled to pre-fund the care wants of their very own retirements. There must be a greater interim financing answer.

Article content material

The monetary elephant within the room is a posh, excessive stakes downside that may have an effect on us all. We on the NIA are dedicated to tackling the query of ample and sustainable LTC financing, together with taking classes from nationwide LTC insurance coverage packages from world wide. However as we transfer ahead, it’s vital that our options are evidenced-based and designed for a future that’s going to look very totally different than the previous.

Bonnie-Jeanne MacDonald is the director of economic safety analysis on the Nationwide Institute on Ageing (NIA) at Toronto Metropolitan College, a fellow on the Canadian Institute of Actuaries, and resident scholar at Eckler Ltd. Dr. Samir Sinha is the director of well being coverage analysis on the NIA; and the Director of Geriatrics at Sinai Well being System and the College Well being Community in Toronto. Alyssa Brierley is the manager director on the NIA.