Key Player In Biden Documents Removal Was Caught Up In Bill Clinton-Era Chinagate Scandal

By Paul Sperry for RealClearWire

The custodian of Joe Biden’s vice presidential data, a key witness in his categorized paperwork probe, was caught up in one other paperwork scandal whereas working on the Commerce Division through the Clinton administration, court docket data reveal.

Longtime Biden aide and gatekeeper Kathy S. Chung, who has been interviewed by federal prosecutors and congressional investigators within the Biden case, was a part of a workforce sanctioned for withholding and even destroying key paperwork within the federal case that sought delicate data from a central determine within the so-called Chinagate fundraising investigation of the late Nineteen Nineties, RealClearInvestigations has realized completely.

A particular prosecutor is now investigating whether or not Biden unlawfully dealt with prime secret supplies in early 2017, when he tasked Chung with eradicating bins containing categorized paperwork from the White Home and storing them at numerous non-public workplaces in D.C., together with the Chinatown neighborhood. A few of the extremely delicate papers additionally ended up at his residence in Wilmington, Del.

Noting that Chung got here into Biden’s orbit by way of working with the president’s son, Hunter, through the Nineteen Nineties, congressional investigators need to know if the Biden household dealings in China have something to do with the stockpiling of categorized paperwork. They notice that the mishandling of White Home papers passed off through the 14-month interval in 2017-2018 when the Chinese language had been wiring virtually $6 million in funds to Hunter and his uncle Jimmy Biden with out offering any recognized official providers. They’ve expressed concern that the funds, which had been flagged by the U.S. Treasury Division, had been a part of a Chinese language intelligence-gathering operation.

Chung is central to the Justice Division’s investigation of Biden’s breach of categorized paperwork.

On Jan. 4, federal brokers interviewed Chung whereas working with an investigative workforce led by U.S. Lawyer John Lausch, who was tasked to conduct a preliminary probe of the safety breach. Alarmed by what his investigators reported again to him about Chung’s position within the attainable unlawful removing and retention of state secrets and techniques, Lausch urged Lawyer Common Merrick Garland to nominate a particular counsel. The next day Garland complied, naming veteran federal prosecutor Robert Okay. Hur to take over the felony case as particular counsel. Hur’s workplace reportedly has obtained greater than 100 pages of paperwork from Chung, together with emails and textual content messages.

Whereas Donald Trump and Mike Pence are additionally beneath investigation for eradicating categorized paperwork from the White Home and storing them at their non-public residences, GOP congressional investigators say comparisons to Trump and Pence miss the purpose. In interviews with RCI, they insisted that Biden’s doc scandal is doubtlessly extra critical than simply mishandling state secrets and techniques. They think it might mushroom right into a counterespionage case involving China and nationwide safety, although the White Home dismisses such hypothesis as “baseless.”

Chung’s lawyer Invoice Taylor didn’t return a request for remark. However in an earlier assertion, he scolded Republicans for “suggesting somebody is a traitor with none proof.”

Chung’s twin position – as an aide to Joe Biden when he was vice chairman and a pal of Hunter Biden, who emails present obtained delicate data from Chung from his father’s workplace – additional highlights the murky ethics that exist between the Biden household’s public service and enterprise pursuits.

Hunter Biden and Chung have a protracted historical past courting again to their days working collectively on the Commerce Division throughout Invoice Clinton’s presidency. It was there that Chung – a longtime Democrat working within the federal paperwork – turned a witness in a case involving convicted Chinagate fundraiser Jian-Nan “John” Huang, who was a prime Commerce official.

In 1993, President Clinton named Huang, a China-born banker pal from Little Rock, deputy assistant secretary of worldwide financial affairs at Commerce, the place he was answerable for Asian commerce issues. Inside a month, Huang was given a prime secret safety clearance and obtained twice-weekly intelligence briefings by CIA analysts. On the identical time, it was later revealed, he was assembly frequently with Chinese language diplomats and different officers tied to Beijing.

Watchdog group Judicial Watch sought paperwork regarding Huang’s entry to commerce secrets and techniques and his journeys to China. Chung was one of many directors answerable for producing such paperwork beneath the Freedom of Info Act.

However the division was sanctioned for withholding and even destroying key paperwork within the federal case ‒ Judicial Watch Inc. v. U.S. Division of Commerce, et al ‒ through which Huang was listed because the lead defendant. After U.S. District Choose Royce Lamberth dominated Commerce’s search “grossly insufficient” and “illegal,” Chung and her superiors had been ordered to conduct one other search. Nonetheless, Chung got here up quick in producing Huang-related paperwork from the pc of her boss, Melissa Moss, within the Workplace of Enterprise Liaison, based on her sworn declaration within the case, a duplicate of which was obtained by RCI. A Clinton appointee like Hunter Biden, Moss labored with Huang on controversial Asian and different overseas commerce junkets for Democrat donors. She got here to Commerce from the Democratic Nationwide Committee, the place she had served as finance director.

“In performing this search, I used to be assisted by an worker of the Pc Assist Desk who knowledgeable me that some paperwork couldn’t be opened,” Chung informed the court docket within the 1999 affidavit, which was by no means uploaded to PACER, the digital federal court docket data system. (After a number of requests to the court docket, Leayrohn King, a data clerk for the U.S. District Courtroom for D.C., supplied RCI a duplicate of Chung’s declaration and commented that it was odd that it was lacking from PACER. The court docket has since made it obtainable within the on-line docket system.)

Chung, who now works as a prime aide to Protection Secretary Lloyd Austin, was in a roundabout way accused of wrongdoing. However attorneys for Judicial Watch complained her division was masking up for Huang, whom they suspected was buying and selling authorities secrets and techniques and entry to China.

Whereas Chung remained on the Commerce Division, Huang left to work for the Clinton reelection effort. He raised virtually $3 million for the DNC and Clinton in 1996, half of which was later discovered unlawful or improper and returned as a result of the donations got here from overseas sources, lots of them tied to Beijing.

The Justice Division, by way of a specifically appointed task force, investigated Huang as a attainable “agent of affect” for China. In 1999, Huang pleaded guilty to a felony violation of marketing campaign finance legal guidelines for arranging unlawful overseas donations. Although the felony cost carries a most penalty of 5 years in jail, he was sentenced to 1 yr of probation and agreed to cooperate with prosecutors of their investigation of a number of co-conspirators.

After Hunter Biden left the Commerce Division in 2001, the place he served as govt director of e-commerce coverage, he joined a Okay Road legislation agency based by William Oldaker, a serious political donor of his father. Data obtained by RCI present attorneys for Oldaker, Biden & Belair LLP represented one other boss of Chung on the Commerce Division within the ongoing FOIA case, which wasn’t settled till 2004.

A decade later, Hunter really useful his father rent Chung as his private assistant within the Workplace of Vice President, based on emails discovered on his deserted laptop computer. Beginning in July 2012, Chung was answerable for overseeing then-Vice President Biden’s workplace affairs, together with dealing with his briefing books and scheduling his journey overseas. She dealt with the small print for Hunter Biden’s controversial 2013 journey to Beijing with the vice chairman, throughout which Hunter met with Chinese language funding companions and organized for his father to shake one among their palms. Emails present Chung additionally invited Hunter to attend a 2015 lunch with Chinese language President Xi Jinping on the State Division.

In January 2017, as Biden moved out of the White Home, Chung helped pack 13 bins with recordsdata from his workplace cupboards and retailer them at a transition workplace close by, based on a partial transcript of Chung’s latest deposition taken behind closed doorways on the Capitol. Round July 2017, Chung reloaded the bins in her automobile and moved them to a non-public workplace that she leased within the Chinatown neighborhood of Washington, earlier than they ended up early the following yr on the China-funded Penn Biden Heart in D.C., based on the transcript.

The bins turned out to include dozens of extremely categorized paperwork, together with ones so secret they might solely be considered in a Delicate Compartment Info Facility, or SCIF. But they had been discovered final yr in an unlocked storage room on the heart that required no key to entry. (The White Home initially claimed, falsely, they had been saved in a “locked closet.”) Prosecutors are investigating the chain of custody of these loosely saved intelligence papers to find out whether or not any had been copied or handed by way of overseas palms.

Chung, who held a High Secret safety clearance and had expertise dealing with and figuring out categorized paperwork, informed congressional investigators she was unaware the bins contained categorized materials – though a few of the file folders within the bins had been emblazoned with cowl sheets stating they contained secret authorities paperwork. She insisted she by no means observed any categorized papers or noticed any categorized markings, though she unpacked the bins when she relocated them to the middle after which re-packed them final summer season on the request of Biden’s attorneys.

A minimum of 20 extremely categorized papers marked on the High Secret/Delicate Compartmented Info degree had been discovered on the heart, which the FBI searched earlier this yr. The supplies reportedly lined Ukraine, Iran, and the UK, amongst different overseas nations.

Chung helped Biden analysis his 2017 memoir, “Promise Me, Dad.” It’s not recognized if Biden or Chung referenced any of the supplies from the bins for his e book, which was revealed in November 2017 and revealed insider accounts of Biden’s numerous roles in U.S. overseas coverage, together with Ukraine. Biden listed Chung first amongst folks he acknowledged for his or her contributions: “Thanks for all of this, and extra, to Kathy Chung.”

Associated: LinkedIn Censors GOP Presidential Candidate Vivek Ramaswamy for Commenting on Biden’s Ties to China

Overlapping Scandals?

Hunter first made contact with Chinese language executives with CEFC China Vitality, a suspected entrance for Chinese language intelligence, in 2015. Emails discovered on Hunter’s deserted laptop computer present a CEFC adviser organized a non-public Washington dinner in December 2015 with Hunter and then-CEFC Chairman Ye Jianming, who reportedly has ties to the Chinese language army.

In an e mail Chung despatched to Hunter Biden that very same yr, she included an inventory of private cellular phone numbers for high-profile Washington officers, together with then-White Home chief of employees Denis McDonough, then-Lawyer Common Loretta Lynch, and a number of other Cupboard secretaries, in addition to Invoice Clinton, Hillary Clinton, and quite a lot of highly effective senators and members of Congress.

Home Oversight Committee Chairman James Comer speculated that Hunter might have been attempting to “show his price to those those who had been paying these monumental sums of cash to him,” partly by “exhibiting them he had cell numbers for highly effective people.”

Chung continued her dealings with Hunter Biden after she left the White Home. On Feb. 2, 2017, shortly after Chung packed up Biden’s White Home recordsdata, Hunter emailed Chung to ask her to “come work with me … in order that I could make everybody cash.” The subsequent yr, messages discovered on Hunter’s laptop computer present Chung despatched Biden relations a hyperlink to an encrypted messaging app known as Sign and urged them to put in it on their digital units.

Later in February 2017, Hunter obtained an $80,000 diamond from Ye, who left the uncommon gem with a thank-you notice at Hunter’s lodge room after they met in Miami. In an interview with The New Yorker journal, Hunter admitted taking the costly stone, although he says he doubts it was meant as a bribe.

Comer mentioned he’s investigating whether or not the Bidens’ Chinese language companions “had entry to the categorized paperwork discovered.” He famous that Hunter Biden, in 2017, deliberate to share workplace area in D.C. with one other one among his Chinese language companions, Gongwen “Kevin” Dong, who was the CEFC cash man who signed off on the wire funds to the Bidens.

“This degree of entry and alternative raises questions on who had entry to the categorized paperwork,” Comer mentioned.

In November 2017, one other Biden accomplice from China ‒ CEFC’s Patrick Ho ‒ was arrested by FBI brokers on costs of bribery and cash laundering. In response to federal documents obtained by RCI, the FBI raided CEFC’s D.C.-area workplaces shortly after Ho’s arrest and searched them for proof. The FBI had been “electronically monitoring” Ho as a suspected Chinese language spy beneath a International Intelligence Surveillance Act wiretap warrant, the documents additional reveal.

Inside months of studying his Chinese language accomplice had been arrested, property data present Hunter terminated the lease on his personal D.C. workplace and closed the ability, the place he’d made keys for each Dong and his father, Joe Biden, based on emails discovered on his deserted laptop computer. That very same month – February 2018 – the previous vice chairman opened a D.C. workplace for the China-funded Penn Biden Heart, the place Hunter maintained entry.

It’s not recognized if any White Home data had been saved at Hunter’s Georgetown workplace or transferred from there to the Penn Biden Heart about 4 miles away. The middle is hosted by the College of Pennsylvania, which has obtained a number of million {dollars} from nameless Chinese language sources since opening the middle. However Hunter’s association together with his Chinese language benefactors clearly raised counterintelligence alarms on the FBI, which started monitoring their communications. For no matter motive, the Bidens had been by no means prosecuted as unregistered overseas brokers and their very own workplaces had been by no means raided. Biden’s unauthorized removing and storage of categorized intelligence went unnoticed – till after the 2022 congressional elections.

Chung, who labored on Biden’s 2020 marketing campaign, was grilled on Capitol Hill about her entry to and dealing with of categorized data in April. She gave sworn testimony to the Home Oversight Committee for roughly 4 hours behind closed doorways.

Comer steered earlier this yr in a Fox Information interview that his investigators had been trying into attainable ties between Chung and the Chinese language Communist Celebration. Fox host Maria Bartiromo requested if Chung was “reporting again to the CCP about any of” the previous vice chairman’s paperwork, and Comer replied, “We’re trying into that.”

Added Comer, “We’re trying into no less than three completely different those who Hunter Biden was immediately concerned with which have very shut ties to the Chinese language Communist Celebration.”

Associated: Joe Biden ‘Will Be Impeached’ Over Report Allegedly Linking Him to ‘Criminal Scheme,’ Says MTG

Ties to Chinese language Communists

Comer famous that when Chung was within the White Home, she fed Hunter Biden delicate data on U.S. political leaders that he mentioned Beijing would covet. In her April 4 interview with Home Oversight investigators, Chung denied having a relationship with the CCP, based on excerpts of her testimony launched by Democrats earlier this month.

Chung additionally insisted she by no means shared categorized data with anybody who wasn’t cleared to learn it, which ostensibly would come with Hunter Biden. Rep. Jamie Raskin, the rating Democrat on the Oversight panel, said Comer was spreading falsehoods based mostly on a “bigoted conspiracy concept.”

Home investigators need to know what the Chinese language acquired for the huge funds they wired to President Biden’s son, brother, and a number of other different relations. Have been they utilizing their contacts with the Bidens to collect U.S. intelligence? Have been any White Home data saved at Hunter’s Georgetown workplace, the place his Chinese language companions had entry?

In a latest letter to Hunter Biden, Comer requested, beneath risk of subpoena, that the president’s son present any paperwork in his possession designated “categorized” authorities property, together with any communications with Dong, Ho, Ye, and different CEFC officers. Individually, he has requested the College of Pennsylvania for an inventory of people that had keycard entry to the Penn Biden Heart. He additionally requested directors flip over the customer logs for the middle.

“It’s crucial to grasp whether or not any Biden relations or associates gained entry to the categorized paperwork whereas saved on the Penn Biden Heart,” Comer mentioned.

In response to emails discovered on Hunter’s laptop computer, Joe Biden was a silent accomplice within the CEFC deal that netted his son and brother thousands and thousands. The paperwork present Hunter claiming that 10% of the Chinese language funds had been put aside for “the large man.” Former accomplice Tony Bobulinski has confirmed that “the large man” was Joe Biden.

CEFC is the capitalist arm of Chinese language President Xi’s “Belt and Highway Initiative” to unfold China’s affect all over the world whereas gobbling up oil and fuel rights. China has sought to affect highly effective officers, notably to realize entry to U.S. vitality markets, that are closely regulated.

Among the many categorized paperwork Biden reportedly had faraway from the West Wing are delicate compartmented briefings about Iran, the place Beijing has been injecting billions of {dollars} in direct overseas funding to extract low cost oil.

“It will be affordable to suspect that Ye and his associates meant to make use of their contacts with Jim [Biden] and Hunter to collect intelligence” about such important overseas nations, mentioned Ben Schreckinger, creator of “The Bidens: Contained in the First Household’s Fifty-12 months Rise to Energy.”

Bobulinski says the Chinese language weren’t trying to make a “wholesome” return on funding, however reasonably had been partnering with the Bidens “as a political or affect funding.” He famous the CEFC companions had been Chinese language intelligence and understood the worth of the Biden title.

In a Might 2017 e mail, Jimmy Biden supplied Hunter, Bobulinski, and different companions an inventory of pleasant American political contacts whom they might exploit to advance the proposed three way partnership with their Chinese language companions. Among the many “key home contacts” had been Democratic Sen. Chuck Schumer of New York; then-Democratic New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo; former Democratic Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe; and then-Democratic Sen. Kamala Harris of California, who would go on to develop into Biden’s vice chairman.

Republicans have slammed Biden for being gentle on China. When Beijing flew a large spy balloon throughout the continental U.S. and picked up extremely delicate knowledge from U.S. army websites, Biden didn’t order Protection Secretary Austin to shoot down the spycraft for a number of days, and solely after public outcry.

In July 2021, Biden named his trusted aide Chung a prime assistant to Austin, the place she has entry to delicate Pentagon data. The Pentagon and White Home declined to reply questions in regards to the degree of Chung’s entry to categorized army intelligence and the extent of her position in dealing with such materials.

Syndicated with permission from RealClearWire.

The opinions expressed by contributors and/or content material companions are their very own and don’t essentially replicate the views of The Political Insider.